Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

10 most over - hyped cars

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #31
    Re: 10 most over - hyped cars

    Originally posted by 2K2BIRD View Post
    How much marketing? Whether it was meant to be limited production or not, I'd say more than - NONE. If I was Ford, it really wouldn't matter how many SUVs I was selling (totally different market, totally different assembly plants), at the end of 2003 when my total production of the 02 & 03 models had not reached the projected 50K combined production goals, I would have added all the available LS goodies for as low a price increase as possible and readvertised the car in a serious marketing campaign designed to let people know they were still out there and better than before.

    During that time frame most people that had been turned off by dealer greed in 02 did not know that you could now buy one for a decent discount. In fact, I've met plenty of people and I bet everyone has, that didn't even know that Ford had made them at all - so again marketing was a problem.

    It wasn't hard to see one on the show room floor in 02 because plenty of dealers had jacked up the price and they weren't selling. The car mags were favorable toward the car at the time, even though they revised their tune later on, but in general car mag articles only reach gearheads - they don't reach all of the folks with disposable income who want a fun extra car, want something to make their daily lives less drab or rich wives that want the flavor of the day.

    Camparing the kind of advertising needed for a Corvette, which had essentially the same formula (two seat sports car) for almost 50 years at the time the retrobirds came out, to a totally changed vehicle from the last model in the line like the new bird was/is not even relevent from what I can tell. About the only similarity in the two cars is the # of seats, despite people constantly trying to compare them. It's like all those comparisons we have seen between the Mustang and the Corvette over the years when Chevy discontinued the Camaro - apples to oranges.

    At least we agreed on two out of three of the reasons -
    So, with all the marketing wizards that work for Ford, they all shot themselves in the foot by bringing out a very nice car and not marketing it properly. Doesn't make sense, if you think about it. I assume that a lot of marketing guys lost their jobs as a result.

    Every major car show had the TBird on display, and most people that go to these shows are not certified car nuts; they are shoppers.

    If marketing was an issue, why did the first year model sell very well at inflated prices? Potential buyers knew that there was a 2002 TBird, but didn't know there was an 03/04/05?

    Of course the SUV and TBird use different assembly lines. That's not the point.

    Maybe the success of the 2002 model made Ford believe that future improvements weren't required. (Model improvements are not planned at the last minute. Maybe they planned the 03 model improvements, saw the success of the 2002, and then ceased any real improvements after 2003. Same with the Lincoln LS.)

    The relevance is that while the Corvette and TBird don't appeal to the same market, they are both limited production vehicles, and the Vette keeps going with it's original concept in mind, with very little marketing, while the TBird's been just about everything except a station wagon.

    And, looking back, while some Vette generations may have been a little weak, GM keeps building the car and pushing improvements.

    I saw 2002 TBirds on the floor with the very popular "market adjustment" pricing as soon as the cars were available for sale, not after the cars had been out for a while. Some dealers even had the car roped off to show "exclusivity". You don't do that if you're trying to sell a car that's not selling.

    When sales went down and the car price dropped, TBirds were sent to the back of the line.

    (I saw two black/saddle 2003s in two local NJ dealerships, both times, the car was either in the back of the lot (with other Birds) or in the back of the dealership, not on the main showroom floor. Both dealers had dropped the price to list, but with a little persuasion, they both agreed to the Ford Z plan discount, so I bought mine.)

    Anyway, I've got one, so Im OK, and we can agree to disgree.

    Cheers:
    Last edited by jerrym3; Jun 3, 2012, 06:51 AM.
    2010 Explorer Limited Edition, tri color white, camel interior
    2003 TBird black/saddle
    1964 Ford Galaxie 500XL conv't turq/black
    2004 Lincoln LS 8 Sport light tundra metallic/medium stone

    Comment


    • #32
      Re: 10 most over - hyped cars

      If sales slip, step up the marketing. Ford didn't.
      I regularly watch Thunderbird memorabilia on eBay. Every day there will be at least two new pages of TBird magazine ads for collectors. These ads run from '55 through the '90s. Not one for retros; only an occasional dealer brochure.
      - Ted
      Titusville, Florida
      We're all Bozos on this bus.

      Comment


      • #33
        Re: 10 most over - hyped cars

        Originally posted by jerrym3 View Post

        The relevance is that while the Corvette and TBird don't appeal to the same market, they are both limited production vehicles, and the Vette keeps going with it's original concept in mind, with very little marketing, while the TBird's been just about everything except a station wagon.

        Cheers:
        Even a Woody!


        sigpic

        “THE EDGE,
        there is no honest way to explain it
        because the only people who really know where it is
        are the ones who have gone over.”

        Comment


        • #34
          Re: 10 most over - hyped cars

          Not to belabor a point, but Ford has a long history of dropping the ball in marketing and built up brand equity, so yes I would say those folks they are paying in this area don't always do the best job. Of course, its jt my on so I could be wrong.

          Some of the cases of questionable marketing/brand equity that come to mind to me without thinking too hard:

          Torino - dropped from the line-up while it was still a very good selling model.

          Taurus SHO (1989-1999) - Same problem as the retrobird: unique model that they did not advertise very well. They seemed to have learned from this mistake as they have advertised the 2010-2013 models much better with a resulting increase in percentage of total Taurus sales.

          Taurus (2007) - decision made to drop the nameplate of what had been the best selling car in the US in the '90s (Mulally saw the folly of this and reversed the decision).

          Thunderbird - letting one of the most recognizable Ford nameplates essentially die with no revival in sight.
          21 years, 174K miles, 48 States X 2 & DC, 9 Canadian provinces, 8 European countries, 3 Caribbean Islands, 3 Hawaiian Islands, 100+ National Park locations, 150+ T-bird events, 190+ retrobird diecasts/models, 13 TOTM pics & some very special friends...THANKS TBN !

          Comment


          • #35
            Re: 10 most over - hyped cars

            [QUOTE=wcoates;477333]
            The T-Bird has all needed buttons. trunk release at your fingertips, 6 cd player, heated seats,one touch top, auto steering wheel adjustment, select shift.

            IMHO it is the one car that can fill both the week-end summer toy role and daily driver role equally well.
            QUOTE]

            Have now owned 14 different 2 seat convertibles. Without a doubt the Bird is the best. Top up 'cause of weather today and it drove as good as any 4 door sedan family car I've ever owned.
            Bill Coates-Canfield, Ohio
            2003 -THE GREY GHOST- MSG, Saddle with Saddle dash kit, door panels, boot and visors

            Comment


            • #36
              Re: 10 most over - hyped cars

              Reading this has just made me decide to go drive mine .. think I'll run out and get some lunch..

              Comment


              • #37
                Re: 10 most over - hyped cars

                What other two seater can carry two sets of golf bags in the trunk? I love it.

                Comment


                • #38
                  Re: 10 most over - hyped cars

                  Originally posted by mrzip View Post
                  What other two seater can carry two sets of golf bags in the trunk? I love it.
                  That's why I feel this 2-seater is unique and not replaceable. I don't golf, but the luggage space means we can take off for weeks. Can't do that with a Miata or a Lambo or anything in between.
                  - Ted
                  Titusville, Florida
                  We're all Bozos on this bus.

                  Comment


                  • #39
                    Re: 10 most over - hyped cars

                    Originally posted by JAB02LHS View Post
                    Even a Woody!


                    Last edited by Larro; Jun 4, 2012, 05:12 PM. Reason: Love that woody!!

                    Comment


                    • #40
                      Re: 10 most over - hyped cars

                      The green car looks like a large Pinto ran up, and into, a bullet bird.
                      2010 Explorer Limited Edition, tri color white, camel interior
                      2003 TBird black/saddle
                      1964 Ford Galaxie 500XL conv't turq/black
                      2004 Lincoln LS 8 Sport light tundra metallic/medium stone

                      Comment


                      • #41
                        Re: 10 most over - hyped cars

                        Eh! I think nothing of it. I don't think the writer was incorrect, and I don't think he was especially hard on our T-Birds. But I don't know they were "over-hyped" either. Ford had to know they were niche cars from the get-go. I mean, a 2-seater with a trunk barely big enough for two suitcases?! But, so what? To most of us who own them, they are our "prized toys" and we don't use them for daily transport. I have an Explorer for that. I love mine for exactly what it is -- it's gorgeous, it's fun to drive, it's fast (I topped 100 MPH three times without trying), and it always turns heads. But that list is pretty interesting. The Tundra has largely flopped here -- if you're buying a full-size pick-up in the US, you're buying a Ford F-series, a Chevy or a Dodge (oops, sorry RAM -- another of Chrysler's marketing disasters). The Vega was a terrible car, but it wasn't euthanized -- it was reborn as the Chevettea few years later; same car, slightly updated. The Edsel has always gotten a bad rap. It was NOT a bad car. It was a Mercury with "adventurous" styling. What everyone forgets is that the Edsel actually sold quite well its first few months -- it nosedived when the recession of 1958 hit. So did every other car in its class -- DeSoto sales fell by 50%; Oldsmobile got hammered; Packards were discontinued. Yes, it's true the electric motor in the early 1958 model transmissions did go bad, but they were covered by warranty and dealers generally replaced trannys with regular issue Ford transmissions (C-6's, if I remember correctly), and they ran forever. The Edsel does not deserve the bad mark it has. I'd love to own one. But I can give you an overhyped car -- the boat-tail Buick Riveras, 1971-73. At the time they came out, they were hailed for their design and some said they'd be worth as much as the originals in a few years. Didn't happen. I had one. It was the worst car I ever had. Everything in it broke down twice. It was no more practical than my '02 T-Bird (the trunk was about the same size and the back window was so small, it was very difficult to back up when parking), and while they're an interesting curiosity when they pop up today, they're really not all that collectable. An opinion is an opinion. We all have them.

                        Comment


                        • #42
                          Re: 10 most over - hyped cars

                          Originally posted by 2K2BIRD View Post
                          Not to belabor a point, but Ford has a long history of dropping the ball in marketing and built up brand equity, so yes I would say those folks they are paying in this area don't always do the best job. Of course, its jt my on so I could be wrong.

                          Some of the cases of questionable marketing/brand equity that come to mind to me without thinking too hard:

                          Torino - dropped from the line-up while it was still a very good selling model.

                          Taurus SHO (1989-1999) - Same problem as the retrobird: unique model that they did not advertise very well. They seemed to have learned from this mistake as they have advertised the 2010-2013 models much better with a resulting increase in percentage of total Taurus sales.

                          Taurus (2007) - decision made to drop the nameplate of what had been the best selling car in the US in the '90s (Mulally saw the folly of this and reversed the decision).

                          Thunderbird - letting one of the most recognizable Ford nameplates essentially die with no revival in sight.

                          I agree with evrything in this post... but I think Mulally knows the value of the Thunderbird name and we'll see another version before he retires. It will be another part of his legacy and will probably be a 4 seater ala 1958 - 1965.
                          It will also be an ecoboost V6, just my opinion.
                          sigpic

                          Comment


                          • #43
                            Re: 10 most over - hyped cars

                            Originally posted by 2K2BIRD View Post
                            ........................
                            Taurus SHO (1989-1999) - Same problem as the retrobird: unique model that they did not advertise very well. They seemed to have learned from this mistake as they have advertised the 2010-2013 models much better with a resulting increase in percentage of total Taurus sales..............
                            It didn't help that the V8 SHO that came out in 96-99 had cam failures that could and did destroy some engines and resulted in lawsuits.
                            sigpic
                            2010 Jaguar XK coupe
                            1995 Lexus SC300 (aka Toyota Soarer)
                            1985 Honda Nighhawk "S"
                            2013 Lexus RX350 - wife's
                            2013 Mercedes E-350 coupe



                            Comment

                            Working...
                            X